Amnesty Accuses Ukrainian Forces Of Endangering Civilians, Sparking Angry Response From Kyiv

(Article text Copyright © 2022 RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave NW, Ste 400, Washington DC 20036. – rferl.org – Todd Prince – Aug. 4, 2022 – article text also appeared at rferl.org/a/ukraine-amnesty-endangering-civilians/31974059.html)

Ukrainian forces have been accused by Amnesty International of endangering civilians by basing themselves in residential buildings, schools, and hospitals, sparking a strong response from Kyiv.

Amnesty International Secretary-General Agnes Callamard said the group’s researchers documented “a pattern of Ukrainian forces putting civilians at risk and violating the laws of war when they operate in populated areas” as it released its report on August. 4.

The report, which the Kremlin and Russian media have already quoted extensively, is an attempt to “shift responsibility from the aggressor to the victim,” Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy said in his nightly video address.

“There is not and cannot be, even hypothetically, any condition under which any Russian strikes become justified. Aggression against our state is unprovoked, invasive, and frankly terroristic,” he said.

Earlier on August 4, Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba said the rights group had drawn a “false equivalence” between the actions of Russia’s invading forces and Ukrainians defending their homeland.

“This behavior of Amnesty International is not about finding and reporting the truth to the world, it is about creating a false equivalence — between the offender and the victim, between the country that destroys hundreds and thousands of civilians, cities, territories, and a country that is desperately defending itself,” he said.

Ukrainian Minister of Defense Oleksiy Reznikov called the report a “perversion” for questioning the right of Ukrainians to defend their country.

“Any attempts to even in passing equate the unprovoked Russian aggression and Ukraine’s self-defense, like it is done in the Amnesty International report, is evidence of losing adequacy and a way to destroy one’s authority,” he wrote.

Callamard said being in a defensive position “does not exempt the Ukrainian military from respecting international humanitarian law.”

She tweeted later on August 4 that Ukrainian and Russian “social media mobs and trolls” were attacking Amnesty International.

“This is called war propaganda, disinformation, misinformation. This won’t dent our impartiality and won’t change the facts,” she said.

The human rights organization said it found evidence of Ukrainian forces launching strikes from within populated residential areas and basing themselves in civilian buildings in 19 towns and villages in three regions of the country. It said its researchers collected the data between April and July.

The report said survivors and witnesses of Russian strikes in the Donbas, Kharkiv, and Mykolayiv regions told Amnesty International researchers that the Ukrainian military had been operating near their homes around the time of the strikes, exposing the areas to retaliatory fire from Russian forces.

“Amnesty International researchers witnessed such conduct in numerous locations,” the report said.

Amnesty also said it found Ukrainian forces using hospitals as military bases in five places, which the human rights group called “a clear violation of international humanitarian law,” which requires the parties to a conflict “to avoid locating, to the maximum extent feasible, military objectives within or near densely populated areas.”

But the report also stressed that the “Ukrainian military’s practice of locating military objectives within populated areas does not in any way justify indiscriminate Russian attacks.”

It also said that in locations where Amnesty International concluded that Russia had committed war crimes “the organization did not find evidence of Ukrainian forces located in the civilian areas unlawfully targeted by the Russian military.”

Presidential adviser Mykhaylo Podolyak on Twitter accused Amnesty International of participating in Moscow’s disinformation campaign to discredit Ukraine’s armed forces.

“Today, Moscow tries to discredit the Armed Forces of Ukraine in the eyes of Western societies and disrupt weapons supply using the entire network of influence agents,” Podolyak said. “It is a shame that the organization like @amnesty is participating in this disinformation and propaganda campaign.”

The report aligns with the narrative that Russia is justified in launching attacks on civilian areas because Ukrainian fighters have set up positions there.

“We’re talking about it all the time, calling the actions of Ukraine’s armed forces the tactics of using the civilian population as a ‘human shield,’” Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova wrote on Telegram.