Firing of Ekho Moskvy Reporter Prompts Speculation Over Fate of Editor-in-Chief

Aerial View of Kremlin and Environs

(Moscow Times – – Anna Dolgov – November 7, 2014) A state-controlled media holding has fired an Ekho Moskvy radio journalist, citing ethical norms, and threatened to dismiss the radio station’s long-standing chief editor who has led it as one of the final strongholds of media freedom in the country.

The dismissal of Alexander Plyuschev followed a Twitter post in which the journalist commented on the drowning death this week of the 37-year-old son of Kremlin chief of staff Sergei Ivanov, referring to an incident in 2005 when Alexander Ivanov hit and killed a 68-year-old retiree with his car. Plyuschev questioned whether the “death of Ivanov’s son, who ran over an old lady and sued her son-in-law, is proof of the existence of God/higher justice?”

He subsequently deleted the tweet and apologized for it.

Gazprom Media, the media arm of state energy giant Gazprom that owns a 66 percent share in Ekho Moskvy, fired Plyuschev on Thursday. The company did not specify the exact reason for Plyuschev’s dismissal, saying only that he had been fired for “violating all permissible moral and ethical norms,” according to a statement cited by RBC newspaper. The media holding’s head, Mikhail Lesin, also said that the decision had to do “with morals,” Forbes Russia reported.

Plyuschev had recently hosted a talk show about fighting at Donetsk Airport in eastern Ukraine, in which he interviewed journalists who have covered the crisis. The show got Ekho Moskvy a government warning for “information justifying war crimes.” The transcript of the program, which aired in late October, has been pulled from the Ekho Moskvy website, and the radio station could be shut down if the government issues a second warning within a year.

Ekho Moskvy journalists said Plyuschev’s firing violated their radio station’s charter, which gives the editor-in-chief the sole power to dismiss editorial staff.

Editor-in-chief Alexei Venediktov, whose trademark glasses and mane of frizzy gray hair are almost as much a symbol of the radio station as its official logo, said he would ignore the Gazprom Media ruling.

“This order, as far as I am concerned, has no force,” he told Ekho Moskvy in a late evening program Thursday. “Alexander Plyuschev remains a journalist of Ekho Moskvy. As to whether his programs will be broadcast: They will be broadcast.”

But continued defiance puts Venediktov’s own job in danger. Lesin said that continuing to resist Gazprom Media’s decision would make it “quite possible” that Venediktov could also be fired, and that “lawyers would figure out” how to justify it, RBC reported.

Venediktov told news website that the threat of losing his own job did not frighten him.

“I have been prepared for death since birth, and I am always prepared for dismissal: This position isn’t smothered with honey,” he was quoted as saying. “If [Lesin] wants to fire me, he has leverage. But nobody should try to threaten me.”

Venediktov, a prominent figure in Russian society, told his radio station that he had spoken to Lesin several times on the phone late into the night on the eve of Plyuschev’s dismissal, with Lesin demanding that the radio host be fired.

The editor said he had told Lesin he would think about what action should be taken, but that he would not fire Plyuschev.

By the early afternoon the following day, Plyuschev had been notified of his dismissal.

“The general director summoned me and told me I was fired,” he wrote on Twitter. “I haven’t seen the paperwork. [Venediktov] learned about it from me.”

Ekho Moskvy has emerged as the leading independent voice on Russia’s airwaves since the collapse of the Soviet Union. But it has come under repeated attacks during President Vladimir Putin’s rule, during which most of the other independent media voices in Russia have already been brought under Kremlin control.